In This Section
|
« Rock the Cradle
Episode Recap: Judge's Pick
Tonight the judges picked the songs for the contestants. But before the babies could rock the cradle, we saw some intense backstage footage: Poor little Lara was crying, Jesse was trash-talking and showing off his conceited side, all kinds of shenanigans. Since there were only five contestants left and an hour of time to fill, the three finalists san two songs but the rejects also got to sing once.
Crosby Loggins: Larry chose Weezer’s “Beverly Hills” and The Fray’s “Over my Head.” Papa Kenny advised his son to just let go and smile (he just needs cut loose!) which he did. Though the back up dancers were kind of odd and probably didn’t need to be there. Waving his hands and singing with the fans, Crosby really worked the crowd. The judges totally dug it and praised his performance.
“Over My Head” really suited Crosby and also allowed him to show off his piano skills (reason #13 I have giant crush on Crosby Loggins). Out of nowhere Crosby left the piano to walk through the crowd, where did the shy indie rocker go? The “thank you” after his performance echoed like that a real rock star.
Jesse Blaze Snider: My Jesse, aren’t we a bit miffed about Belinda’s comments! After watching some some angry video, Jesse sang Larry's choices, “Are You Gonna My Girl?” by Jet and The Living End’s “Prisoner of Society.” The Jet song was OK. I feel like Jet performs it with so much energy and lots of fun screams but Jesse was kind of toned down…which is fine when you have the talent to do mellow songs, but Jesse isn’t that great so he needs the flips and the craziness to distract/entertain us.
Best moment of the night: Belinda called Jesse out on his trash talking and nasty attitude “I’ve been making music for 30 years, I think I know what I’m doing,” she told him. Oh man Belinda is such a badass—she’s still got the beat, no question!
“Prisoner of Society” was the perfect song for Jesse to sing in terms of the lyrics that perfectly describe his bratty attitude and because it didn’t require much vocal talent. The back flip made a comeback and the performance was high-energy. I didn’t think he could pull off The Living End, but he did. I liked it! Even Belinda gave him a 10…
Lara Johnston: Singing Fergie’s “Big Girls Don’t Cry” and rocking a pair of tight leather pants, tonight was probably Lara’s best performance. She connected with the song, she looked appropriately cute…too bad she was voted off! But in a personal triumph, June was finally pleased!
Lucy Walsh: Super sweet footage of Lucy and her father Joe bonding and getting involved with the music. (I miss you, dad!) Lucy struggled through “My Immortal” by Evansecence in rehearsal because it made her think of her dad. She got through the whole thing on stage, but this chick has a whiny voice. Great piano and very emotional, but the voice was whiny. She was fun, but I can’t say I’m too sorry to see Lucy go. Sidenote: Was it me, or was Lucy a little too upset about leaving Jesse? Perhaps a budding rock romance?
Chloe Lattanzi: We got a glimpse of Chloe’s dad and her favorite past time of chanting in his teepee (WOW). Larry chose “Toxic” by Britney Spears and “First Cut is the Deepest” by Sheryl Crow and Chloe was in tears over singing a Spears track. (But is there ever time when she’s not crying about something?) Chloe worked her…uh stage props (aka a man tied to a chair) and despite her initial tears really got into song. Flipping her hair and shooting flirty looks, this girl was embracing her inner Britney! Larry praised her every move, but I still can’t understand all of the words this girl sings.
Call me crazy, but I kind of liked “First Cut is the Deepest.” This is first time I understood what Chloe was singing and wasn’t creeped out by anything she did on stage! She’s not the best and she won’t win, but way to end with a performance that doesn’t frighten, Chloe.
At this point it’s between Jesse and Crosby (receiving scores of 39 and 38 respectively) and will come down to what America wants: Legit talent or high-energy performance. If Jesse sticks to punk rock, I’d go see him in concert and I haven’t really made it a secret that if Crosby sang anything I’d go see him in concert (let’s be honest). As long as Chloe doesn’t win, I’ll be happy.
So which performance was your favorite? Do you agree with the results? Who else thinks something might be going on between Jesse and Lucy? Who’s going to take it all?
|
|
|
|
May 2, 2008 11:11 AM
|
Part of me was surprised to see Lucy go and Chloe stay, but I have to say that I never really got into Lucy. Her voice was just too whiny for me to really enjoy the ballads that she often sang. Chloe wasn't as bad as other nights last night and I'm glad, that way she earns her spot in the final.
In terms of people improving, I was really glad that Lara did so well with Big Girls Don't Cry. She left after her strongest performance and while she wasn't the best, she was definitely good. However, I agree with the judges and how they commented on Crosby improving from week to week and really taking the most advantage of the process.
I really hope that Crosby wins. Hopefully people will vote based on talent and entertainment. I wholeheartedly agree with your comments on Jesse - entertaining on times, but just kind of blah and ridiculously conceited.
Quick random observation - Larry made a big deal out of Chloe making Toxic "her own." Uh, what was he watching? That performance was a karaoke version of the music video, right down to the guy in the chair and dance moves. Larry of all of the judges should have recognized that.
|
|
May 2, 2008 12:32 PM
|
|
I loved how humble both of the Loggins' are. Kenny's comment about all the growth from everyone was so sweet. I think Jesse will win for flash but that we will see Crosby around for a long time.
|
|
May 2, 2008 2:28 PM
|
Well, it clearly looks like the vote for the worst type rabble-rousers have taken hold of this show. There's NO WAY Chloe should still be there over Lucy. Sorry.
Loggins SHOULD win, but I'm VERY worried that Chloe WILL win. Nobody's watching or talking about this series, so it very easy could fall prey to hooligans. I'll laugh a hearty laugh if Chloe wins.
|
|
May 2, 2008 8:00 PM
|
I will never understand how Chloe has outlasted all the other girls. From the start I said she was the worst of the females and I stand by that.
I sure hope Crosby wins!
|
|
May 5, 2008 4:30 PM
|
|
|
